Mag. Asita Aue
In its decision of March 18, 2026 (6 Ob 60/25d), the Supreme Court again had to decide on the reduction of the rent under § 1096(1) ABGB and in particular on the question of an implied waiver of this right.
As a general rule: If a property during its term of possession is so defective that it is unfit for intended use, the interest exemption or reduction in rent pursuant to § 1096, paragraph 1, second sentence, ABGB shall apply ex lege from the beginning of the unsuitability or impairment of use of the property until its rectification. Already paid rent may be recovered in principle or added to ongoing or future rent claims.
However, a special feature exists when payment of the rent is made without reservation in the knowledge of the defect. According to consistent case law, such conduct can be considered an implicit waiver of the rent reduction under the provisions of § 863 ABGB. The relevant factor is whether the landlord could understand the tenant’s behavior as a waiver under the circumstances of the individual case.
In the specific case, a commercial premises was affected by a construction site. The tenant repeatedly pointed out the impairment and its economic difficulties to the landlord and unsuccessfully requested a reduction in the rent. Nevertheless, she continued to pay the rent in full because she did not want to jeopardize the further business relationship with the landlord.
The OGH confirmed that the appellate court was entitled to assess this conduct as an implicit waiver of the rent reduction. What was decisive was in particular that the tenant was aware of the impairment of the use and that there were no comparable uncertainties regarding the legal or factual conditions, as in previous decisions.
Therefore, it is relevant in practice: The mere knowledge of a defect does not automatically lead to the loss of the right of reduction. However, a payment without reservation can – depending on the specific circumstances – be considered a waiver. For tenants, it is therefore advisable not to make a payment of rent without providing appropriate clarification or reservation in case of disputed disruptions.

